Where Eagles Dare: Book Review
Where Eagles Dare, written by Alistair Maclean and published in 1967, was a critical and commercial success, and critics regard it as a classic of the spy thriller genre.
Where Eagles Dare: Title
The title of Where Eagles Dare is an inter-textual reference to Shakespeare’s Richard III:
The world is grown so bad, that wrens make prey where eagles dare not perch.
This kind of figurative allusion is a classic title generation technique.
(For more on titles, see How to Choose a Title For Your Novel)
Where Eagles Dare: Logline
During World War Two a team of British spies attempt to rescue an American general from an impregnable castle in the German Alps but, when they discover there are double agents in the group, the team must discover who the traitors are and then escape against enormous odds.
(For more on loglines see The Killogator Logline Formula)
Where Eagles Dare: Plot Summary
Warning: Major spoilers are blacked out like this [blackout]secret[/blackout].
It’s early in 1944. The Germans have shot down and captured General George Carnaby, one of the planners of the upcoming D-Day invasion. They’ve taken Carnaby to the Schloss Adler, the Bavarian SS headquarters. The Schloss Adler is on top of a mountain, with only a cable car for access, and so practically impregnable.
Colonel Turner and Admiral Rolland of MI6 assemble a team to rescue the general. The leader is British Major John Smith. The other members of the team are MI6 agents, except for Morris Schaffer who is in the American OSS.
The British team parachute into Germany, near the Schloss Adler. On landing they discover the radio operator with his neck broken. Smith realises it wasn’t an accident, so there must be a double agent on the team. Smith backtracks to meet with another MI6 agent, Mary Elison, who’s following them, unknown to the rest of the team.
The British team infiltrates the village below the castle and Smith introduces Mary to Heidi, another British agent posing as a barmaid. Mary and Heidi travel on the cable car to the Schloss Adler.
German troops surround the bar and capture the British team. Smith and Schaffer escape, cause a diversion by setting fire to the train station, and then travel to the Schloss Adler on the roof of the cable car. When they get near the castle, they jump onto the roof, and Mary helps them climb in through a window. Schaffer disables the German’s helicopter, and Smith cuts the telephone lines to isolate the castle.
At the Schloss Adler
Smith and Schaffer sneak into the hall of the Schloss Adler, where they find General Carnaby being interrogated by a German general. The other three members of the British team arrive and reveal that they are all double agents.
Entering the hall, Smith disarms Schaffer and tells the Germans that in fact he is the double agent, General Carnaby is not really a general and the three supposed double-agents are impostors who are really there to kidnap the German General.
Smith invites the Germans to contact his superiors to prove that he is really a double agent. They do so, and are convinced. Smith suggests the three impostors should prove they are genuine German agents by writing down the names of Germany’s top agent in Britain and all the German spies they know, which he will compare with a list in his possession. The three write their lists with Smith looking on and scoffing.
When they finish, Smith reveals his list. It’s blank. Smith is a triple agent and has tricked the double agents into revealing most of Germany’s spies.
Schaffer holds all the Germans at gunpoint. One of the Germans gets the upper hand again, but then Mary comes to the rescue.
Smith drugs all the Germans and announces he is taking the three double agents back to Britain to be hung as traitors. Schaffer sets explosives as a diversion. Smith destroys the radio so the castle can’t call for reinforcements from the village, and the group head to the cable car. Whilst getting down from the roof of the castle to the cable car station, though, the traitors overpower Schaffer and use the cable car to escape…
Hanging From a Thread
Smith [blackout]jumps from the roof of the castle onto the roof of the cable car. He fights one traitor on the roof of the cable car and is nearly shot but one of the cable car supports hits the traitor, sending him to his death. Smith sets an explosive charge and then jumps to the other cable car as it passes. The explosion kills the remaining traitors.[/blackout]
Smith [blackout]returns to the cable car station, where Schaffer has bolted the two steel doors, keeping them safe for a while. Smith, Schaffer, Mary and Carnaby ride the cable car back down to the village. They jump out into the snow when the Germans finally break down the cable car station doors and stop their descent. On the mountain, the explosions have set the castle on fire and it has turned into an inferno.[/blackout]
They [blackout]meet Heidi and head to the airfield in the post-bus. German soldiers and a tank chase them, but they escape by blowing up a rickety bridge. They reach the airfield, where Colonel Turner is waiting for them with a plane to take them to Britain.[/blackout]
In [blackout]the air, Smith reveals the name of Germany’s top agent – as confirmed by the traitors – Colonel Turner. Smith explains the mission’s real objective: to unmask the double agents, first the minor agents on the rescue team and, more important, Colonel Turner himself, who Admiral Rolland already suspected. Admiral Rolland called in Smith, Mary and Schaffer to unmask Colonel Turner because they were the only people he could trust.[/blackout]
Colonel Turner [blackout]tries to shoot Smith, but his gun has been deactivated. He commits suicide by jumping out of the plane without a parachute.[/blackout]
(For more on summarising stories, see How to Write a Novel Synopsis)
Where Eagles Dare: Analysis
Where Eagles Dare has a roller-coaster Mission plot (see Spy Novel Plots), but it’s really all about the twists and the action.
The ‘Mission’ Plot
- Is given a mission to carry out by their Mentor.
- Will be opposed by the Antagonist as they try to complete the mission.
- Makes a plan to complete the Mission.
- Trains and gathers resources for the Mission.
- Involves one or more Allies in their Mission (Optionally, there is a romance sub-plot with one of the Allies).
- Attempts to carry out the Mission, dealing with further Allies and Enemies as they meet them.
- Is betrayed by an Ally or the Mentor (optionally).
- Narrowly avoids capture by the Antagonist (or is captured and escapes).
- Has a final confrontation with the Antagonist and completes (or fails to complete) the Mission.
The story centred on the seemingly impossible mission, and with the twists coming at regular intervals, it compels the reader to turn the pages, desperate to find out ‘what happens next’.
Alistair Maclean’s writing is as brisk and efficient as ever, with little in the way of literary flourish. He does though overuse adverbs, particularly in dialogue: For example this exchange:
“We both prefer French wine,” said Smith apologetically.
“Our top agent in the Mediterranean,” said Kramer wonderingly. “And I’ve never heard of you.”
“Maybe that’s why he is what he is,” said Rosemeyer dryly.
“I’ve been lucky,” said Smith briskly.
As in Ice Station Zebra, the characters in Where Eagles Dare are thin. Alistair Maclean reuses his usual stock characters:
- A cold, unflappable British hero, Smith.
- A tough, wisecracking American sidekick, Schaffer.
- A weak but beautiful love interest, Mary, who seems a bit more nervous than you might expect in a supposed top MI6 agent.
The supporting characters, including all the Germans, have no real characterisation at all; they’re just extras. This kind of shorthand in writing and characterisation might be because Alistair Maclean wrote the book and film script simultaneously.
On the plus side, the writing is punchy, the pace is high, and the twists make sense within the logic of the book. Further, Alistair Maclean is undoubtedly one of the greatest ever writers of an action scene. Inevitably, any book primarily driven by a roller-coaster plot suffers from familiarity after a few reads, but even having read the book and seen the movie multiple times, the fight on top of the cable car is still one of the most gripping scenes ever written.
Where Eagles Dare: Alternative Cover
The heart of the novel is the Schloss Adler. My cover tries to give a sense of its inaccessibility, brooding on top of the mountain.
(For more on book cover design, see How to design a book cover)
Where Eagles Dare: My Verdict
One of the best action-centred, roller coaster rides of a spy novel ever written. Should be on every aficionado’s bookshelf.
Where Eagles Dare: The Movie
Where Eagles Dare was filmed in 1968, starring Richard Burton, Clint Eastwood and Mary Ure. Brian G. Hutton directed it. The soundtrack was by Ron Goodwin, who also scored 633 Squadron.
Because of the way Alistair Maclean wrote the movie simultaneously with the novel, it’s almost identical. The movie is more violent, with the heroes engaging in more gun fights and killing more Germans – the body count approaches a hundred, and Clint Eastwood kills more people in Where Eagles Dare than any of his other films. In contrast, in the novel Smith relies on tricking people, knocking them out, and tying them up. He even backtracks to save a tied up German who is going to burn to death in the castle.
The violence in the movie opens up a plot hole – why does Smith try to take the traitors back instead of killing them? In the book, it’s because he doesn’t enjoy killing people. He says “I’m not an executioner.” But in the movie he’s already killed several people with no remorse.
Want to Read/Watch it?
Here’s the movie trailer
If you’d like to discuss anything in my review, please email me. Otherwise please feel free to share it using the buttons below.